This small group discussion guide draws directly from the sermon “Showcase - Sunday Morning Worship Live Stream” so you can keep engaging with the message all week. Read, reflect, and share it with your small group or friends.
Small Group Discussion Guide
The Way of Wisdom: Factoring in Life and Death
Based on Ecclesiastes 2:12–17 | Shiloh Church
A Note to Facilitators: Welcome! This guide is designed to help your group engage meaningfully with Sunday's sermon on Ecclesiastes 2:12–17. You don't need to be a biblical scholar to lead a great discussion — your job is simply to create space for honest conversation and help people connect God's Word to their lives. Read through the guide before your meeting, choose the questions that feel right for your group, and trust the Holy Spirit to do the rest. All questions are numbered for easy reference.
OVERVIEW
In Ecclesiastes 2:12–17, Solomon — the wisest and wealthiest man of his day — looks back on his life and delivers a sobering conclusion: no amount of wisdom, achievement, or success can give life ultimate meaning if God is left out of the equation. The sermon challenged us to embrace true wisdom, which means factoring in both life and death as we make decisions, set priorities, and pursue purpose. Like a ship that sets sail without the captain on board, a life built on human wisdom alone — no matter how impressive — is ultimately empty. But because Jesus is "the resurrection and the life," there is hope, meaning, and a way upstairs.
SECTION 1: ICEBREAKER
(5–10 minutes)
Question 1. Think about a time you set out to do something — a project, a trip, a plan — and realized midway through that you had forgotten something really important. What happened, and what did you do?
[Leader Tip] This light, story-based question helps people relax and connect before diving into deeper content. It also naturally sets up the sermon's opening illustration about the ship that set sail without the captain. Don't rush this — laughter and storytelling build trust in the group.
SECTION 2: SCRIPTURE READING
(5 minutes)
Have someone read the passage aloud. Invite the group to listen for one word or phrase that stands out to them.
Ecclesiastes 2:12–17 (ESV)
So I turned to consider wisdom and madness and folly. For what can the man do who comes after the king? Only what has already been done. Then I saw that there is more gain in wisdom than in folly, as there is more gain in light than in darkness. The wise person has his eyes in his head, but the fool walks in darkness. And yet I perceived that the same event happens to all of them. Then I said in my heart, "What happens to the fool will happen to me also. Why then have I been so very wise?" And I said in my heart that this also is vanity. For of the wise as of the fool there is no enduring remembrance, seeing that in the days to come all will have been long forgotten. How the wise dies just like the fool! So I hated life, because what is done under the sun was grievous to me, for all is vanity and a striving after wind.
Brief Context for Facilitators: Ecclesiastes was written by Solomon — a king who had everything the world could offer: unmatched wisdom, extraordinary wealth, great building projects, and deep pleasures. Yet after pursuing all of it apart from God, he concluded that life "under the sun" (meaning life lived from a purely human, earthly perspective) is vanity — empty, meaningless, like chasing the wind. This book is Solomon's honest memoir and warning to those who come after him.
After the reading, ask: "What word or phrase stood out to you as that was read? You don't have to explain it — just share what caught your attention."
[Leader Tip] This simple "noticing" exercise helps quieter group members engage early without pressure. It also surfaces the themes the group is already thinking about before the discussion begins.
SECTION 3: DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
(30–45 minutes)
Work through as many of these questions as time allows. You don't need to cover all of them — choose the ones that feel most relevant to your group. Questions are organized from lighter to deeper.
THEME 1: The Pursuit of Wisdom
What Solomon searched for — and what he found
Question 2. The sermon described Solomon as a man who "set sail without the captain on board." In your own words, what does that image mean to you? Have you ever seen someone — or experienced yourself — living that way?
Question 3. Solomon says there is real "gain" or advantage in wisdom over foolishness — he compares it to the difference between walking in the light versus walking in the dark. What are some practical, everyday ways you've seen wisdom lead to better outcomes than foolishness?
[Leader Tip] This question is intentionally accessible and observation-based. Encourage concrete, real-life examples — at work, in relationships, in finances, in parenting. This helps ground the discussion before moving to more personal territory.
Question 4. The sermon made a distinction between wisdom as what you know and wisdom as what you do with what you know. Melvin Wade was quoted as saying, "Wisdom teaches knowledge how to behave." Where do you see that gap — between knowing the right thing and actually doing it — showing up most in your own life?
THEME 2: The Wise Man Lives
Walking in the light
Question 5. The sermon described two kinds of people: one who "walks in the light" and one who "walks in darkness" — and pointed out that this isn't about a single mistake, but a consistent way of life. What does it look like practically to walk in the light day by day? What helps you stay on that path?
Question 6. The pastor shared a story about a college student who complained about living in a dark, immoral dorm — and the pastor's response was, "Have you considered that God may have placed you there to be a light?" How do you respond to that idea? Is there a "dark place" in your life right now — a workplace, a relationship, a neighborhood — where God might be calling you to be a light rather than withdraw?
[Leader Tip] This question can bring up real tension for people. Validate that it's genuinely hard to stay faithful in dark environments. Be careful not to let the discussion become judgmental toward others — keep the focus on personal calling and God's grace, not criticism of "dark" people or places.
THEME 3: The Wise Man Dies
Factoring death into the equation
Question 7. Solomon's central argument is that true wisdom requires factoring in both life AND death. Warren Wiersbe is quoted as saying, "You are not ready to live unless you are ready to die." Why do you think our culture tends to avoid thinking about death? What happens to our priorities and choices when we actually take death seriously?
[Leader Tip] This is the theological heart of the sermon and may feel heavy. Remind the group that Solomon isn't being morbid — he's being realistic. You can normalize the discomfort by acknowledging that this isn't a comfortable topic, but it's one the Bible takes seriously. If the group goes quiet, try the follow-up below.
Optional follow-up if discussion stalls: "Has there been a moment in your life — a health scare, the loss of someone close, a near-miss — that made you think more seriously about your own mortality? How did it change you?"
Question 8. Solomon observes that "the same event happens to them all" — meaning both the wise and the foolish face death. He asks, "Why then have I been so very wise?" That sounds like despair — but the sermon said it's actually an important question. What do you think Solomon is really wrestling with here? And how does the resurrection of Jesus change the answer to his question?
THEME 4: The Wise Man Grieves
Living with eyes open to what matters
Question 9. Solomon says, "So I hated life." The sermon was careful to explain this isn't suicidal despair — it's the frustration of someone who looked at the world and saw how much of it is built on things that don't last. What are some things our culture invests heavily in that, in light of eternity, are ultimately "vanity" — empty or temporary? How do you personally guard against building your life on those things?
Question 10. The sermon ended with the story of Martha and Jesus at the tomb of Lazarus. Martha said, "If you had been here, my brother would not have died" — but then added, "Even now, I know that whatever you ask of the Father, he will give you." The pastor said that's the difference faith makes: you can look at life with all its pain and despair and still say, "Even now, God is still in control." What does "even now" faith look like in your life right now? Where do you need that kind of faith today?
[Leader Tip] This is a powerful closing question for the main discussion. Give people a moment of quiet before inviting responses. Some people may share vulnerable things — receive those with grace and without rushing to fix or advise. Simply affirm and pray.
SECTION 4: PERSONAL APPLICATION
(10–15 minutes)
These questions are for individual reflection. You may invite people to share their responses, or give a few minutes of quiet journaling before discussing as a group.
Question 11. The sermon described three kinds of people: the wise man learns from his own mistakes; the simple man learns from the mistakes of others; the fool doesn't learn anything. Honestly, which of those describes you most right now — and why?
Question 12. The sermon's central image was a ship setting sail without the captain on board. In what area of your life — your work, your relationships, your finances, your future plans — are you most tempted to "set sail" and handle things on your own without truly inviting God to be in charge?
Question 13. Solomon's frustration came from looking for meaning and purpose "under the sun" — in things that are purely earthly and temporary. If you're honest, where are you most tempted to look for meaning, significance, or happiness in things that ultimately can't deliver? What would it look like to redirect that longing toward God?
Question 14. The sermon closed with the invitation: "Today would be a great day to make a U-turn in your life." That invitation is for everyone — not just people who don't know Jesus, but anyone who has drifted. Is there a U-turn God is calling you to make right now? It doesn't have to be dramatic — sometimes it's a small course correction. What might that look like for you this week?
[Leader Tip] Question 14 is intentionally personal and may prompt some meaningful sharing. Be sensitive to the fact that some group members may be at different places in their faith journey. Create space without pressure — you might say, "You don't have to share this out loud if it's too personal, but I'd encourage you to sit with it this week."
SECTION 5: THIS WEEK'S CHALLENGE
Choose one (or more) of the following to put into practice before your group meets again:
Option A — Reflect: Set aside 15 minutes this week for honest reflection. Ask yourself: "Is the Captain on board in this area of my life?" Choose one specific area — work, relationships, finances, health, future plans — and write down what it would look like to genuinely surrender that area to God.
Option B — Engage: Think of one "dark place" in your life — a relationship, workplace, or situation — where you've been tempted to withdraw or write someone off. Commit to one small act this week that brings light into that situation: a kind word, a prayer, a genuine conversation.
Option C — Remember: Read Psalm 90 — Moses' meditation on human mortality and God's eternity — slowly and prayerfully. Notice how Moses moves from acknowledging death to asking God for wisdom and joy. Let it shape how you approach your week.
Option D — Share: Is there someone in your life who is living "without the Captain on board" — searching for meaning in all the wrong places? Commit to praying for them by name every day this week, and ask God for an opportunity to share hope with them.
SECTION 6: PRAYER FOCUS
(5–10 minutes)
Close your time together in prayer. You may pray as a group, in pairs, or have one person pray on behalf of the group. Use the following prompts to guide your prayer:
Suggested Prayer Topics:
🙏 Gratitude — Thank God for the gift of wisdom found in His Word, and for the honest, hard-earned perspective Solomon shares with us in Ecclesiastes.
🙏 Surrender — Pray together that each person in your group would have the courage to invite God — the "Captain" — into every area of their lives, especially the ones they've been navigating alone.
🙏 Eternal Perspective — Ask God to help your group live with eyes open to what truly lasts — to invest in things of eternal value rather than chasing what is temporary.
🙏 Those Without Hope — Pray for people in your lives, your community, and your world who are searching for meaning "under the sun" — that God would use His people to point them to the light.
🙏 "Even Now" Faith — Pray specifically for anyone in your group facing a situation that feels dark, hopeless, or overwhelming — that they would know the resurrection power of Jesus and be able to say, "Even now, God is still in control."
You may want to close with this prayer from the sermon:
"Father, open our eyes that we may behold wondrous things from Your Word. And as You give us understanding, help us to keep Your Word and observe it with our whole hearts. Make our hearts good ground and receptive soil, so that the implanted Word would bring forth fruit — 30, 60, and 100 times more than what is planted. In Jesus' name, Amen."
SECTION 7: OPTIONAL DEEP DIVE
For groups with extra time or those wanting to go further
Deep Dive Question 1. The sermon mentioned that Solomon "came to himself" — like the prodigal son in Luke 15 — and made a U-turn back to God after years of chasing meaning in the wrong places. Read Luke 15:11–24 together. What parallels do you see between the prodigal son's journey and Solomon's journey in Ecclesiastes? What does this story tell us about how God responds when we come to our senses and return to Him?
Deep Dive Question 2. The sermon drew a contrast between life "under the sun" (a purely human, earthly perspective) and life with God. Read Colossians 3:1–4 and Matthew 6:19–21, 33. How do these New Testament passages build on what Solomon is saying in Ecclesiastes? What does it look like practically to "set your mind on things above" while still fully engaging with everyday life here on earth?
Colossians 3:1–4 (ESV): "If then you have been raised with Christ, seek the things that are above, where Christ is, seated at the right hand of God. Set your minds on things that are above, not on things that are on earth. For you have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God. When Christ who is your life appears, then you also will appear with him in glory."
Matthew 6:19–21 (ESV): "Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal, but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys and where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also."
Deep Dive Question 3. The sermon ended with a powerful declaration: "I don't know what the future holds, but I know WHO holds the future." Read John 11:17–27 — the exchange between Jesus and Martha at Lazarus's tomb. Jesus says, "I am the resurrection and the life." How does this claim by Jesus directly answer Solomon's despair in Ecclesiastes 2? In what ways does the resurrection of Christ transform the meaning of Solomon's observation that "the wise dies just like the fool"?
John 11:25–26 (ESV): "Jesus said to her, 'I am the resurrection and the life. Whoever believes in me, though he die, yet shall he live, and everyone who lives and believes in me shall never die. Do you believe this?'"
SUPPLEMENTAL SCRIPTURES FOR FURTHER STUDY
| Passage | Connection to the Sermon |
|---|---|
| Ecclesiastes 1:1–3 | Solomon's introduction and the theme of "vanity" |
| Psalm 1:1–3 | The blessing and fruitfulness of walking in God's wisdom |
| Psalm 90:1–17 | Moses on human mortality and finding meaning in God |
| Proverbs 9:10 | "The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom" |
| John 8:12 | Jesus as the Light of the World |
| John 11:17–27 | Jesus as the Resurrection and the Life |
| Romans 6:23 | The wages of sin is death — but there is a gift |
| Colossians 3:1–4 | Setting our minds on things above, not under the sun |
| 2 Timothy 4:7–8 | Paul's perspective on life, death, and eternal reward |
QUICK-REFERENCE GUIDE FOR FACILITATORS
| Section | Time | Key Goal |
|---|---|---|
| Icebreaker | 5–10 min | Build comfort and connection |
| Scripture Reading | 5 min | Ground the group in God's Word |
| Discussion Questions | 30–45 min | Explore meaning and application |
| Personal Application | 10–15 min | Connect truth to real life |
| This Week's Challenge | 2–3 min | Identify one concrete next step |
| Prayer Focus | 5–10 min | Close with dependence on God |
| Total | 60–90 min |
A Final Word for Facilitators: Your goal isn't to have all the answers — it's to help your group ask better questions and encounter God together. If a conversation goes somewhere unexpected, that's often the Holy Spirit at work. Trust the process, trust the people, and trust the One who promised that His Word will not return empty. Thank you for the gift of your time and leadership. May the Captain always be on board.
Shiloh Church | Small Group Ministry "Where We Connect, Grow, and Serve"